[Mondrian] Native vs. Regular Non Empty <Level>.MEMBERS Issue

[Ajit Vasudeo Joglekar]

I propose the following

We roll back the changes done in change list #10641. After doing this, 
bug: 1722959 will reopen and can be marked as a non issue and bug: 1909516 
will get fixed. As far as 1909516 is concerned it is possible to add check 
around IgnoreUnrelatedDimension and get it working. But this makes 
ValidMeasure dependent on IgnoreUnrelatedDimension which is not a good 
idea. Hence the only way out is to roll back change #10641

As far as the difference in behavior between native non empty and in 
memory non empty (motivation behind bug 1722959) regarding the handling of 
empty rows/ columns with literal "1" calc members is concerned we have 
couple of options:
1) can log a new low priority bug fixing of this will involve changing 
native non empty behavior to not to eliminate the above said rows/columns. 
Opposite of bug 1722959
2) document it and live with the difference in behavior. whoever doesn't 
want this native non empty behavior may turn of the the feature using 
property 

Requesting comments

Thanks

-Ajit
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://lists.pentaho.org/pipermail/mondrian/attachments/20080410/57ef9c66/attachment.html